100% independent. Rythium takes no fees, commissions or partnerships from any software or AI vendor. Ever.
Home/Case studies/Microsoft EA renewal

Microsoft EA renewal case study: How a manufacturer cut its renewal by 22% using its own usage data

In this Microsoft EA renewal case study, a manufacturer with 11,000 seats was proposed an all-E5 agreement with org-wide Copilot at $6.8M a year. We rebuilt the license mix on twelve months of usage data. It was signed at $5.3M a year, 22% below the proposal, with three years of price protection.

Client
A manufacturer, 11,000 seats
Term
3 years
Outcome
Signed at $5.3M a year

The situation

Microsoft proposed moving all 11,000 seats to E5 with Copilot, at $6.8M a year, 34% more than before

  • The renewal proposal moved the entire organization to E5 and added org-wide Copilot.
  • Both were framed as “where Microsoft is taking the platform.”
  • Proposed spend: $6.8M a year for three years, a 34% increase on the expiring agreement.
  • It was presented ten weeks before the signature deadline.

How we did it

We checked twelve months of usage and found 60% of the proposed E5 seats used nothing beyond E3

  1. 01

    Pull the usage data

    We pulled twelve months of usage data and mapped every proposed license against it.

  2. 02

    Read the usage

    60% of the proposed E5 seats used nothing beyond E3 plus two security add-ons. Copilot interest was real, but concentrated in two departments.

  3. 03

    Rebuild the mix

    We rebuilt the license mix seat by seat.

  4. 04

    Negotiate on evidence

    We ran the negotiation on that evidence, including an 800-seat Copilot pilot that has to prove its value in place of the 11,000-seat commitment.

EA renewals are usually decided months before signature, when the account team sets out what you need. Your own usage data is the fairest check on that forecast.

The results

The agreement was signed at $5.3M a year, 22% below the proposal, with three years of price protection

Microsoft's proposal, all E5 with Copilot, a year$6.8M
Signed agreement, rebuilt on usage, a year$5.3M
$1.5M a year, $4.5M over the term

22%Cut from the proposed annual spend

60%
Of the proposed E5 seats moved to E3 plus add-ons
3 yr
Price protection secured

What we delivered

E5 seats
60% of the proposed E5 seats moved to E3 plus add-ons
Copilot
An 800-seat pilot in place of 11,000 seats
Price protection
On the pilot-to-rollout conversion, so success doesn't get repriced later

EA renewal in the next 12 months?

Send us the renewal proposal. A senior advisor will tell you within 24 hours whether there’s money on the table, and how we would run your Microsoft EA renewal.

Start with the dataMicrosoft EA renewal

Who leads our engagements

Independent licensing advisors since 2015: 260+ engagements, led by a former Oracle Vice President

Sheshagiri Anegondi
Expert-ledSheshagiri Anegondi

Managing Partner of Rythium Technologies. A former Oracle Vice-President (1998 to 2015) who now sits on the buyer’s side, and author of “Licensing Oracle”.

Anil Nahata
Expert-ledAnil Nahata

Co-founder of Rythium Technologies and its designated partner since 2015.

Ritesh Verma
Project delivery managerRitesh Verma

Vice President, Delivery and Operations at Rythium Technologies. Former CIO of Indian Oiltanking, with a 25-year career implementing Oracle applications.

Questions about this case study

How was the Microsoft EA cut by 22%?

We mapped every proposed license against twelve months of usage data. 60% of the proposed E5 seats used nothing beyond E3 plus two security add-ons, so we rebuilt the mix seat by seat and negotiated on that evidence. The agreement was signed at $5.3M a year against a $6.8M proposal.

What happened to the org-wide Copilot commitment?

Copilot interest was real but concentrated in two departments. In place of 11,000 seats we negotiated an 800-seat pilot that has to prove its value, with price protection on the pilot-to-rollout conversion.

How much did the client keep?

$4.5M over the three-year term.

When should an EA renewal start?

Early. EA renewals are lost in the framing stage, months before signature. In this case the proposal arrived ten weeks before the signature deadline.

Related

More case studies

  1. 08Microsoft CopilotA pharma company800 Copilot seats tested before committing to 12,000
  2. 09Broadcom / VMwareA retailerA 340% VMware renewal quote cut by 58%
  3. 10IBMA telecom companyAn $8.1M IBM audit claim cut to $400,000

Every case study, by publisher and issue: all case studies

Your renewal quote deserves a redline of its own.

Send us the quote, the demand letter or the proposal. A senior advisor will tell you within 24 hours whether there's money on the table.

Request a confidential review
WhatsAppChat with an advisor

Cookie settings

Strictly necessaryKeep the site working and remember your cookie choice.
Always on