100% independent. Rythium takes no fees, commissions or partnerships from any software or AI vendor. Ever.

The Hidden Costs of a Java SE License, and How to Tame Them

A Java SE license costs more than the price on Oracle’s list. This article sets out the hidden costs of Java SE licensing, and how to tame them.

When managing Java SE Licensing you must be aware of the direct costs and potential hidden costs that can significantly impact your budget. These hidden costs can arise from various factors, including oversight in licensing third-party contractors and unexpected company growth.

 

What are the cost challenges with using Oracle Java?

The hidden costs of Java SE Licensing are most commonly:

  1. Oracle’s Employee Metric definition.
    The definition includes
    1. The internal employees of an organization and
    2. All external agents and contractors.

This definition is actually quite elastic and, as we have seen, it has been used to brow-beat customers into purchasing much larger number of licenses than actually used.

  1. Unplanned Growth in number of employees:
    1. Oracle might sell you a contract for a fixed period (between 3 to 7 or 8 years).
    2. This contract has a specific number of employees mentioned and licensed.
    3. Your total number of employees increases during the term of the contract

The increase in the number of employees later on leads to the need for making additional license payments to Oracle.

  1. Audit Penalties
    1. While most of the Java audits are soft audits, we are seeing an increasing number of deals where Oracle is insisting on getting paid for ‘past’ usage of Java.
    2. These penalties can range from 1 year to 3 years in the past.

Audit penalties have historically been used by Oracle to brow-beat customers into paying huge license fees. This continues with the sales process for Java SE licenses.

What should customers be doing?

Treat Java like any other software you pay for. Know what you run, what it is worth to you and what you owe before Oracle sets the terms. We break this into five steps.

  1. Find every Java installation. Discover the Java installations and files on your servers and endpoints. Put the data into one consistent format and classify each installation by vendor and license agreement. Then check your entitlements, because Java can come licensed with other Oracle products or under third-party agreements.
  2. Remediate and rebalance. Each installation needs two decisions, one on security and one on cost. Some Java is free and some is not, depending on its licensing terms, and the patches you need to fix vulnerabilities shape the choice. You can remediate with Oracle or non-Oracle Java.
  3. Weigh the alternatives. Plan where you can avoid Oracle Java completely and where you can use only pre-licensed or free Oracle Java. Two things decide it: compatibility with your current applications, and the cost of migrating, if there is one.
  4. Estimate a value-based price. Oracle’s employee metric does not let you negotiate on usage or on the value Java gives you, so work out the price you should be paying with more than one pricing method. Put Java SE licensing costs into your growth and expansion plans too, since a rising employee count means more license payments.
  5. Agree the rules before you talk to Oracle. With the deployment data and the cost estimate in hand, decide who speaks to Oracle, what is shared, when, why, and how much data Oracle sees.

Potential Savings

Across our engagement with more than 23 clients on Java license advisory, we have found that customers who follow the above process can save between 30% to 100% of their potential Java license exposure.

Sheshagiri Anegondi

The Java Tax: Why Oracle’s New Pricing is Costing You Millions

What the Java tax is, how Oracle's per-employee pricing works, and why large companies overpay without noticing.

Short · 0:29Watch on YouTube

Rythium’s Java License Advisory Service

Rythium provides its Java License Advisory service to customers facing challenges with Java SE licensing. We have worked with a couple of dozen customers and helped them win against Oracle.

The scope of work includes:

Unveiling Your Java Footprint

The service begins with a thorough discovery of your Java deployments. We identify all instances, including Oracle Java, non-Oracle Java, and OpenJDK. This detailed inventory provides a clear picture of your current Java usage.

Expert Analysis and Strategic Guidance

Our team of licensing specialists then analyzes the discovered deployments in relation to your existing Oracle Java agreements and third-party entitlements. This process ensures accurate license classification and entitlement alignment.

Actionable Insights and Recommendations

Following the analysis, we provide a comprehensive report outlining your license requirements and potential areas for optimization. We offer recommendations for remediation and rebalancing your Java footprint, including strategic advice on Oracle deal structuring.

Negotiation Support and Advocacy

For clients navigating Oracle licensing discussions, we offer expert support. Our team assists with crafting communications, developing negotiation strategies, reviewing commercial offers, and participating in negotiations to secure the most favorable terms.

Key Benefits

  • Reduced compliance risk: Gain peace of mind with a clear understanding of your Java licensing obligations.
  • Cost optimization: Identify potential savings opportunities and achieve optimal license utilization.
  • Improved efficiency: Streamline Java management with a comprehensive inventory and insightful recommendations.
  • Expert guidance: Leverage the knowledge and experience of our seasoned licensing specialists.

 

Java license changes how to plan your oracle java negotiations

 

Read more about our Managing Partner, Sheshagiri Anegondi, who worked at Oracle from 1998 to 2015 and wrote the book Licensing Oracle.

In case you want to understand the key issues to be considered in choosing between Oracle and non-Oracle Java, you can click here.

About the author

Sheshagiri Anegondi

Managing Partner of Rythium Technologies. Seventeen years at Oracle, from 1998 to 2015, in leadership roles including Vice President Sales, after Compaq and Digital Equipment Corporation.

Author of “Licensing Oracle: The Reference Manual for Managing Oracle License Compliance & Procuring Oracle Software, Hardware, Cloud & Services” (2021, ISBN 10: 1639046887).

More about Sheshagiri Anegondi

See more of our analysis in Google: add Rythium as a preferred source

Read next
  1. Effective Java License Management with Euladox SAM-As-A-ServiceOracle's Java metric changes and audit risks, and how Euladox discovery and SAM-as-a-Service find every Java installation and keep you compliant.
  2. Lessons from DeepSeek about Reducing Oracle License CostsDeepSeek showed what doing more with less looks like. What it teaches about Oracle and enterprise software costs, and how far those costs can come down.
  3. OpenJDK vs Oracle JDK: Differences in License, Support and CostOpenJDK vs Oracle JDK: who builds each, the license terms, what each costs in production, which Oracle JDK versions are free, and one client's move to OpenJDK.
WhatsAppChat with an advisor

Cookie settings

Strictly necessaryKeep the site working and remember your cookie choice.
Always on